Ecologically-Smart Cities: Keeping Urban Ecosystems Centre Stage in India’s Smart Cities Programme

Harini Nagendra
Azim Premji University, India

All images by the author.
Hover your mouse over a picture to see its caption.

On a path of accelerated urbanization, India is going through substantial changes in its land cover and land use. In 1950, shortly after Indian independence, only 17% of the country’s population lived in cities. Today, India’s urban population stands at 33%. India contains three of the world’s ten largest cities, Delhi, Mumbai, and Kolkata; as well as three of the world’s ten fastest growing cities, Ghaziabad, Surat, and Faridabad. In the past two decades, the area covered by Indian cities has expanded by a staggering 250%, covering an additional 5000 square kilometers of India’s surface with concrete, asphalt and glass (Nagendra et al., 2013). Projections indicate that more than 50% of India’s people will be living in cities by 2050 (United Nations, 2014). This massive urbanization will pose large scale challenges for urban resilience and sustainability, especially for the poorest and most vulnerable: the urban poor, migrant workers, traditional village residents.

1. Trees provide shade for all, including vulnerable groups such as street vendors in BangaloreSmart cities, a program of focus of the Indian government, are considered to hold promise to resolve major challenges of urban sustainability. This approach is driven by a belief in the supremacy of technology for the efficient management of urban growth. Yet other, equally if not more significant issues of the importance of nature and the restoration of thriving ecosystems for the well-being and health of people in cities demand equal attention. A systematic focus on urban ecosystems, via the protection of urban commons, is essential to provide a robust, adaptive and resilient pathway towards greater urban sustainability.

The environmental consequences of the rapid growth of cities are starkly apparent. 2. A park in Bangalore provides a refuge for large colonies of the fruit batUrban expansion has degraded and destroyed natural habitats across most Indian cities and small towns, transforming urban forests, lakes and wetlands into polluted travesties of their former ecological vigor, and converting them into vast expanses of concrete construction. Why should we care about the impacts of urbanization on ecosystems? In part, of course, because of their intrinsic value. In addition, though, urban ecosystems are essential for human health and wellbeing, and ultimately, for urban resilience.

3. In the heart of the city, children engage in a time honored favorite activity - climbing trees!Urban ecosystems provide a range of important ecosystem services that are critical for the sustainability of cities. Wetlands clean up water contaminated with industrial pollutants and sewage, while trees strip the air of pollutants. For instance, coastal wetlands provide protection against flooding to parts of Navi Mumbai, an extension of the city of Mumbai (Nagendra et al., 2013), while inland wetlands buffer the city of Chennai from flooding during heavy rains (Nambi et al., 2014). Trees in Bengaluru clean polluted air and provide shade for street vendors and pedestrians, reducing the levels of harmful pollutants such as suspended particulate matter and 4. Children from wealthy residential areas and local slums working side by side, painting leaves and stones at an usulphur dioxide (Vailshery et al., 2013). Services such as these are termed as regulating services, because they regulate the environment. Important supporting ecosystem services such as the provision of habitat for migratory birds and bats are provided by urban ecosystems such as the coastal wetlands of Mumbai, and parks in Bangalore (Nagendra et al., 2013).

Urban ecosystems also provide important cultural and recreational ecosystem services. Ecosystems hold an important place in the cultural landscape of urban 5. Goats grazing at a lake in BangaloreIndia through their sacrality and worship (Nagendra et al., 2014). Exposure to green spaces provides well-being and psychological relief from urban stress. Parks, lakes and coastal beaches act as important social nodes of congregation, strengthening social bonds between disparate, anonymous urban residents.

The importance of urban regulatory, supporting and recreational services are widely recognized by the public, and by policy makers and planners. Yet there has been a systematic decline in the availability of urban ecosystems for provisioning ecosystem services across Indian cities. In almost all Indian cities, lakes, tree cover, grasslands and wetlands once provided food, fodder, fuelwood and other important resources. These ecosystem products are still consumed by many, from cattle owners and fishers, to migrant workers and the poor. For instance, the mangroves of Mumbai are used by thousands of local residents for collecting fodder, fuelwood and food, while lakes in many parts of Bangalore continue to provide fodder for cattle, and supply milk and fish to city residents. These areas historically functioned as urban commons, providing collective resources for the entire community in times of scarcity and need.

6. Community protests to save a polluted lake in BangaloreHowever, local planners and governments have permitted the large scale conversion of these areas for urban development. It is only in recent years, in particular after large scale flooding in 2005, that the utility of maintaining mangrove habitats for flood protection and lakes for ground water recharge became recognized, prompting their protection of these habitats (Parthasarathy, 2011). The motivation for such protection has been the urgency to maintain regulatory ecosystem services, while the importance of production services for the resilience of the poorest and most vulnerable has been largely ignored in official planning discourse. For instance, many lakes across Bengaluru are now being restored in response to ground water depletion, in response to citizen protests by affected local communities. Yet the protection of lakes has 7. A sign in Kannada announces that fish are available at a local lake in Bangalorean often ignored, yet important social consequence: while lake ecological condition improves, restored lakes are typically fenced and gated to keep out grazers, washermen (dhobies), fishers and other traditional users.

Urbanization thus not only leads to specific patterns of change in ecosystem use: it also leads to specific types of change in the perceived value of specific types of ecosystem services, shaping wide ranging policies that regulate access to and management of these former urban commons.

Regulatory and recreational ecosystem services have systematically taken 9. Water collected from a depression in a dry lake bed is an important resource, used by the inhabitants of a tenteprecedence over productive uses of ecosystems in the minds of the urban public, the media, and city administration. Associated with this, urban ecosystems have transformed from commons or common pool resources used by communities for shade, water, grazing, fishing and fuelwood collection, to protected lakes, parks and mangrove forests that belong to the state, valued for public ecosystem services such as ground water recharge, recreation and flood protection.

In this process many of the urban poor, whose livelihood resilience, health and nutritional levels depended on access to provisioning ecosystem services, have been the worst affected, losing access to the services provided by 10. An advertisement for a private butterfly park in a new residential complex in Bangalorenatural ecosystems due to the dual processes of privatization for urban land use, and public protection for conservation (Mundoli et al., 2014).

The massive scale of urbanization in India will pose undoubted challenges for the country’s environment, ecology, society and sustainability. Responding to these challenges will require sustained attention to devise and implement appropriate policies for ecologically sustainable urban growth. The current focus on smart cities in8. A tree branch provides shade and shelter for a makeshift cradle, holding the sleeping child of a street vendor i India is driven by a search for technological fixes. Yet the restoration of thriving ecosystems as urban commons, that can ensure the well-being and health of a wide strata of people in Indian cities, demands equal attention. A systematic focus on urban ecosystems is essential, and can provide a relatively inexpensive, adaptive, robust and resilient approach for enhancing urban sustainability. Better protection, management and use of urban ecosystems will be essential for urban sustainability in the era of the Anthropocene.

An ecologically smart city may be the smartest city one can envisage! 11. A newly restored lake in Bangalore has a number of restrictions on access and useSuch an approach would increase the resilience of cities by providing low-cost, adaptive and efficient ways to deal with the challenges of providing safe food, pure water and clean air for unprecedented and growing numbers of people. To create ecologically smart cities, a systematic focus on urban ecosystems is required, restoring their original function as urban commons that provide important provisioning, regulatory, recreational and supporting ecosystem services. Such ecologically smart cities would be low-cost, adaptive, and resilient to a whole host of local and global environmental challenges, from pollution and food insecurity to climate change.

Dr. Harini Nagendra is Professor of Sustainability at Azim Premji University, Bangalore.

Header Image: Bangalore, India.  Credit: Harini Nagendra


4 thoughts on “Ecologically-Smart Cities: Keeping Urban Ecosystems Centre Stage in India’s Smart Cities Programme

  1. agree. in the 70s and 80s there was a lot of thinking about eco-friendly housing, construction technologies, traffic free pedestrian friendly zones, etc. etc. They have all been swallowed by the greed of the construction lobby which in turn feeds the bellies of politicians. The only hope is citizens activism. Uma

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s